StringStripWS - @CR still there - (Moved)

[Jeep]

Hello,

I'm comming from the french site "Autoitsript.fr" with the following question or problem.

I try to use StringStripWS to clean spaces and control characters in a string.  Here is my code.

#include <String.au3>
#include <StringConstants.au3>
#include <Array.au3>


;---- Part 1

Local $sText = @TAB    & "This    is   a  new story." & @CR & @LF & "Once upon a time ...  "
Local $sCheck = ""

$sCheck = StringStripWS($sText, BitOR($STR_STRIPLEADING, $STR_STRIPTRAILING, $STR_STRIPSPACES))
;$sCheck = StringStripWS($sText, $STR_STRIPLEADING + $STR_STRIPTRAILING + $STR_STRIPSPACES)

ConsoleWrite($sCheck & @CRLF)
For $i = 1 to stringlen($sCheck)
    ConsoleWrite(stringmid($sCheck,$i,1) & "-" & Asc(stringmid($sCheck,$i,1)) & @CRLF)
next

; Part 2 --- Workarround submited by "jchd" on he french site
Local $sText = @TAB    & " This    is   a  new story." & @CR & @LF & "Once upon a time ...  "
Local $sCheck = StringStripWS(StringRegExpReplace($sText, "[[:space:]]+", " "), $STR_STRIPLEADING + $STR_STRIPTRAILING + $STR_STRIPSPACES)
ConsoleWrite(">" & $sCheck & "<" & @LF)
_ArrayDisplay(StringToASCIIArray($sCheck))

 

The help file tells  :

  Quote

"Remarks
Whitespace includes Chr(9) thru Chr(13) which are HorizontalTab, LineFeed, VerticalTab, FormFeed, and CarriageReturn. Whitespace also includes the null string ( Chr(0) ) and the standard space ( Chr(32) )."

Expand  

But if we check the console after program execution , the CarriageReturn (Chr(13) is still there. This is a mistake of the program, a bug or a feature of StringStripWS or a mistake in the help file. 

I use AutoIt v3.3.14.5.

We have already a workaround (Part 2). 

Thanks in advance for your replies.

Edited January 26, 2019 by Melba23
Added tags

[Melba23]

Jeep,

Bienvenu au forum Anglophone!

If I use StringStripWS($sText, $STR_STRIPALL) I get the Chr(13) characters removed from the string - which should solve your immediate problem. I will investigate further - but if jchd has to use a workaround it looks like there might well be a bug somewhere.

M23

P.S. When you post code here please use Code tags - see here how to do it.  Then you get a scrolling box and syntax colouring as you can see above now I have added the tags. Thanks in advance for your cooperation.

Edit: No bug - see the works of others below.

 

Edited January 27, 2019 by Melba23

[Melba23]

Moved to the appropriate forum.

Moderation Team

[mikell]

IMHO it' not a bug.
It rather seems that "whitespace" is used in a generic way  ( Whitespace includes ... etc)
$STR_STRIPSPACES (4) = strip double (or more) spaces between words , and in this example it's exactly what it does. This

Local $sText = @TAB    & "This    is   a  new story. " & @CR & @LF & "Once upon a time ...  "

gives the expected result because of the space after the dot

The workaround provided by jchd replaces a vertical WS by a horizontal one, while StringStripWS is not intended to do that

 

[Gianni]

StringstripWS, used with  the $STR_STRIPSPACES (4) flag,  strips double (or more) spaces between words (leaving just only one in place of the 2 or more whitespaces). Now, since @crlf are actually considered as 2 whitespaces, the function it leaves just one of them. So the single space (@cr) left by the function is correct.
It consider @cr @lf.. and all the other "white spaces" as if that are normal spaces chr(32)...

Edited January 26, 2019 by Chimp

[mikell]

  On 1/26/2019 at 1:33 PM, Chimp said:

(leaving just only one in place of the 2 or more whitespaces)

Expand  

I'd rather say : it leaves the first one and fires the others

  On 1/26/2019 at 1:33 PM, Chimp said:

It consider @cr @lf.. and all the other "white spaces" as if that are normal spaces chr(32)

Expand  

I'd rather say : it doesn't care if spaces are horizontal or vertical 

OTOH In the code from jchd the SRER replaces one or more spaces (any) by one Chr(32) , reason why in this code $STR_STRIPSPACES is redundant

[Gianni]

  On 1/26/2019 at 1:49 PM, mikell said:

I'd rather say : ..,

Expand  

I agree
p.s.
accuracy is not my specialty....

[mikell]

My bad. I was not accurate enough too
What I said in my 2nd post should have been mentioned in my first one 

[Jeep]

Thanks everybody for your replies.

Chimp, a special thanks.

If I replace @CR @LF by @LF & @CR in my original string, now i found @LF in the result. If we replace multi spaces char by one, StringStripWS keep the first one. it's a normal behaviour of that function not a bug.

Melba23,

I promise to use "Code tags" the next time :-). There are not on the same place on the french site. Thanks for your welcome (merci pour votre "bienvenue").

Bye 

[Melba23]

Chimp & mikell,

I completely agree with your interpretation of the way in which the function works - my earlier post was in error. Thanks for the efforts to point me in the right direction!

M23