Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
AlexChernavsky

Measuring reaction-time: How to know if results are accurate?

Recommended Posts

AlexChernavsky

I'm working on an AutoIt program that will be used in a psychological study to measure a person's reaction time.  I have a draft of the program completed, and it seems to work.  In other words, the reaction-time data is plausible.

The program displays a random digit between 2 and 8 inclusive (this is called the "target digit").  The user has to hit the corresponding key as quickly as possible.  The program measures the amount of time it takes the user to hit the key.  There are multiple trials per session, and an average reaction-time is calculated at the end of the session.

Here are the two critical AutoIt functions that perform the actual timing. (In the first function, I edited-out some lines of code that display the target digit in a GUI):

Func _PresentProblemAndGetResponse($sProblem, $sAnswer, $hGui)Local $iReactionTime
Local $iCorrect
Local $sLocalTime
Local $avResults[4]
[Edited-out the code that displays the target key in a GUI]
$hBegin = TimerInit() ; Start the stopwatch running
$iCorrect = _GetKeyPress($sAnswer) ; The parameter here is the correct answer (i.e., the solution to the problem). A returned value of 0 means user pressed wrong key; 1 means correct key.
$iDiff = Round(TimerDiff($hBegin)) ; Stop the stopwatch and get elapsed time in milliseconds
$iReactionTime = $iDiff ; This is the user's reaction time in milliseconds
$sLocalTime = _GetTime() ; This is the user's current local time
GUICtrlDelete($hLabelMessage) ; Erase the problem from the GUI
$avResults[0] = $sProblem ; Assign the relevant data to a vector
$avResults[1] = $iReactionTime
$avResults[2] = $iCorrect
$avResults[3] = $sLocalTime
Return ($avResults)
EndFunc   ;==>_PresentProblemAndGetResponse


Func _GetKeyPress($iRightAnswer)
Local $iRightAnswerCode = 30 + $iRightAnswer ; Convert the answer into the ASCII code that's required by the _IsPressed function
Local $iWrongAnswers[10] = [30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39] ; Initialize array of wrong answer digits
$iWrongAnswers[$iRightAnswer] = '20' ; Replace the right answer with the code for the space character
While 1
For $x = 0 To 9
If _IsPressed($iRightAnswerCode) Then Return (1)
If _IsPressed($iWrongAnswers[$x]) Then Return (0)
Next
WEnd
EndFunc   ;==>_GetKeyPress

 

So, I have two questions.  The second question is much harder, I think.

First of fall, does my approach seem like a reasonable way to measure the time between displaying a target number and registering a user's keypress?  If not, what's a better approach?

Second, how can I verify that the results are accurate?  I've run the program over a hundred times (using myself as the subject), and the results are about what I would expect.  Actually, my main interest lies in measuring small changes that take place over the course of many sessions performed over weeks or months.  The absolute precision isn't terribly important, but consistency is very important.  In other words, if the results are high by 5%, that's not too much of a problem, as long as they are consistently high by 5%.

Thanks for considering my questions.

 
 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Andreik

Hi Alex, this could be a way to get the response time of a digit from the screen.

HotKeySet('1','Correct')
HotKeySet('2','Correct')
HotKeySet('3','Correct')
HotKeySet('4','Correct')
HotKeySet('5','Correct')
HotKeySet('6','Correct')
HotKeySet('7','Correct')
HotKeySet('8','Correct')
HotKeySet('9','Correct')

Global $Correct = False, $Counter = 1, $Max = 10, $Random, $Last, $Total

$hMain = GUICreate("Reaction Time Measure")
$hDigit = GUICtrlCreateLabel('',100,0,200,50,0x01)
$hResponseTime = GUICtrlCreateEdit('The test will display ' & $Max & ' digits, one digit each time. You have to press the button of the digit you see it.',0,200,400,150,0x0800)
GUICtrlSetFont($hDigit,30,900,1,'Arial Black')
$hButton = GUICtrlCreateButton("Start test",125,360,150,35)
GUISetState(@SW_SHOW,$hMain)

While True
    Switch GUIGetMsg()
        Case -3 ;GUI_EVENT_CLOSE
            Exit
        Case $hButton   ; Test will start
            ControlDisable($hMain,"",$hButton)
            Test()
            ControlEnable($hMain,"",$hButton)
    EndSwitch
    Sleep(10)
WEnd


Func Test()
    GUICtrlSetData($hResponseTime,"")
    Do
        Do
            $Random = Random(1,9,1)
        Until $Random <> $Last
        GUICtrlSetData($hDigit,$Random)
        $Timer = TimerInit()
        Do
        Until $Correct
        $Diff = TimerDiff($Timer)
        $Correct = False
        $Counter += 1
        $Total += $Diff
        $Last = $Random
        GUICtrlSetData($hResponseTime,Round($Diff,3) & @CRLF,1)
        Sleep(10)
    Until $Counter = $Max
    GUICtrlSetData($hDigit,"")
    GUICtrlSetData($hResponseTime,@CRLF,1)
    GUICtrlSetData($hResponseTime,"Average response time: " & Round($Total/$Max,3),1)
EndFunc

Func Correct()
    If @HotKeyPressed = $Random Then $Correct = True
EndFunc

Usually, native functions are faster then UDFs, so I like more this way. But if you still want to use _IsPressed be sure you open user32.dll and use the handle as second parameter of the function otherwise the dll will be opened every time you call the function. This may lead to different response time and for a test like yours this may be relevant.

My example is raw but can be improved to work as you like. Hope this was helpful in any way.


When the words fail... music speaks

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
AlexChernavsky

Hello AndreiK,

Thank you for the detailed answer.  I will try your suggestions this weekend.  For now, I'll mark the question as answered, although I think I'll eventually post again about my second question (regarding precision / accuracy in the results).

Thanks again.

-- Alex Chernavsky

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

  • Similar Content

    • TheDcoder
      By TheDcoder
      Hello Guys! I wanted to share all my knowledge on arrays! Hope may enjoy the article , Lets start!
      Declaring arrays!
      Declaring arrays is a little different than other variables: 
      ; Rules to follow while declaring arrays: ; ; Rule #1: You must have a declarative keyword like Dim/Global/Local before the declaration unless the array is assigned a value from a functions return (Ex: StringSplit) ; Rule #2: You must declare the number of dimensions but not necessarily the size of the dimension if you are gonna assign the values at the time of declaration. #include <Array.au3> Local $aEmptyArray[0] ; Creates an Array with 0 elements (aka an Empty Array). Local $aArrayWithData[1] = ["Data"] _ArrayDisplay($aEmptyArray) _ArrayDisplay($aArrayWithData) That's it
      Resizing Arrays
      Its easy! Just like declaring an empty array! ReDim is our friend here:
      #include <Array.au3> Local $aArrayWithData[1] = ["Data1"] ReDim $aArrayWithData[2] ; Change the number of elements in the array, I have added an extra element! $aArrayWithData[1] = "Data2" _ArrayDisplay($aArrayWithData) Just make sure that you don't use ReDim too often (especially don't use it in loops!), it can slow down you program.
      Best practice of using "Enum"
      You might be wondering what they might be... Do you know the Const keyword which you use after Global/Local keyword? Global/Local are declarative keywords which are used to declare variables, of course, you would know that already by now , If you check the documentation for Global/Local there is a optional parameter called Const which willl allow you to "create a constant rather than a variable"... Enum is similar to Const, it declares Integers (ONLY Integers):
      Global Enum $ZERO, $ONE, $TWO, $THREE, $FOUR, $FIVE, $SIX, $SEVEN, $EIGHT, $NINE ; And so on... ; $ZERO will evaluate to 0 ; $ONE will evaluate to 1 ; You get the idea :P ; Enum is very useful to declare Constants each containing a number (starting from 0) This script will demonstrate the usefulness and neatness of Enums :
      ; We will create an array which will contain details of the OS Global Enum $ARCH, $TYPE, $LANG, $VERSION, $BUILD, $SERVICE_PACK Global $aOS[6] = [@OSArch, @OSType, @OSLang, @OSVersion, @OSBuild, @OSServicePack] ; Now, if you want to access anything related to the OS, you would do this: ConsoleWrite(@CRLF) ConsoleWrite('+>' & "Architecture: " & $aOS[$ARCH] & @CRLF) ConsoleWrite('+>' & "Type: " & $aOS[$TYPE] & @CRLF) ConsoleWrite('+>' & "Langauge: " & $aOS[$LANG] & @CRLF) ConsoleWrite('+>' & "Version: " & $aOS[$VERSION] & @CRLF) ConsoleWrite('+>' & "Build: " & $aOS[$BUILD] & @CRLF) ConsoleWrite('+>' & "Service Pack: " & $aOS[$SERVICE_PACK] & @CRLF) ConsoleWrite(@CRLF) ; Isn't it cool? XD You can use this in your UDF(s) or Program(s), it will look very neat!
      Looping through an Array
      Looping through an array is very easy! . There are 2 ways to loop an array in AutoIt!
      Simple Way:
      ; This is a very basic way to loop through an array ; In this way we use a For...In...Next Loop! Global $aArray[2] = ["Foo", "Bar"] ; Create an array ; This loop will loop 2 times because our $aArray contains 2 elements. For $vElement In $aArray ; $vElement will contain the value of the elements in the $aArray... one element at a time. ConsoleWrite($vElement & @CRLF) ; Prints the element out to the console Next ; And that's it! Advanced Way:
      ; This is an advanced way to loop through an array ; In this way we use a For...To...Next Loop! Global $aArray[4] = ["Foo", "Bar", "Baz", "Quack"] ; Create an array ; This loop will loop 2 times because our $aArray contains 2 elements. For $i = 0 To UBound($aArray) - 1 ; $i is automatically created and is set to zero, UBound($aArray) returns the no. of elements in the $aArray. ConsoleWrite($aArray[$i] & @CRLF) ; Prints the element out to the console. Next ; This is the advanced way, we use $i to access the elements! ; With the advanced method you can also use the Step keyword to increase the offset in each "step" of the loop: ; This will only print every 2nd element starting from 0 ConsoleWrite(@CRLF & "Every 2nd element: " & @CRLF) For $i = 0 To UBound($aArray) - 1 Step 2 ConsoleWrite($aArray[$i] & @CRLF) Next ; This will print the elements in reverse order! ConsoleWrite(@CRLF & "In reverse: " & @CRLF) For $i = UBound($aArray) - 1 To 0 Step -1 ConsoleWrite($aArray[$i] & @CRLF) Next ; And that ends this section! For some reason, many people use the advance way more than the simple way . For more examples of loops see this post by @FrancescoDiMuro!
      Interpreting Multi-Dimensional Arrays
      Yeah, its the most brain squeezing problem for newbies, Imagining an 3D Array... I will explain it in a very simple way for ya, so stop straining you brain now! . This way will work for any array regardless of its dimensions...
      Ok, Lets start... You can imagine an array as a (data) mine of information:

      ; Note that: ; Dimension = Level (except the ground level :P) ; Element in a Dimension = Path ; Level 2 ----------\ ; Level 1 -------\ | ; Level 0 ----\ | | ; v v v Local $aArray[2][2][2] ; \-----/ ; | ; v ; Ground Level ; As you can see that $aArray is the Ground Level ; All the elements start after the ground level, i.e from level 0 ; Level 0 Contains 2 different paths ; Level 1 Contains 4 different paths ; Level 2 Contains 8 different paths ; When you want too fill some data in the data mine, ; You can do that like this: $aArray[0][0][0] = 1 $aArray[0][0][1] = 2 $aArray[0][1][0] = 3 $aArray[0][1][1] = 4 $aArray[1][0][0] = 5 $aArray[1][0][1] = 6 $aArray[1][1][0] = 7 $aArray[1][1][1] = 8 ; Don't get confused with the 0s & 1s, Its just tracing the path! ; Try to trace the path of a number with the help of the image! Its super easy! :D I hope you might have understand how an array looks, Mapping your way through is the key in Multi-Dimensional arrays, You take the help of notepad if you want! Don't be shy!
      Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) & Their answers
      Q #1. What are Arrays?
      A. An Array is an datatype of an variable (AutoIt has many datatypes of variables like "strings", "integers" etc. Array is one of them). An Array can store information in a orderly manner. An Array consist of elements, each element can be considered as a variable (and yes, each element has its own datatype!). AutoIt can handle 16,777,216 elements in an Array, If you have an Array with 16,777,217 elements then AutoIt crashes.
      Q #2. Help! I get an error while declaring an Array!?
      A. You tried to declare an array like this:
      $aArray[1] = ["Data"] That is not the right way, Array is a special datatype, since its elements can be considered as individual variables you must have an declarative keyword like Dim/Global/Local before the declaration, So this would work:
      Local $aArray[1] = ["Data"] Q #3. How can I calculate the no. of elements in an array?
      A. The UBound function is your answer, Its what exactly does! If you have an multi-dimensional Array you can calculate the total no. of elements in that dimension by specifying the dimension in the second parameter of UBound
      Q #4. Why is my For...Next loop throwing an error while processing an Array?
      A.  You might have done something like this:
      #include <MsgBoxConstants.au3> Local $aArray[10] = [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10] Local $iMyNumber = 0 For $i = 0 To UBound($aArray) ; Concentrate here! $iMyNumber += $aArray[$i] Next MsgBox($MB_OK, "Sum of all Numbers!", $iMyNumber) Did you notice the mistake? UBound returns the no. of elements in an array with the index starting from 1! That's right, you need to remove 1 from the total no. of elements in order to process the array because the index of an array starts with 0! So append a simple - 1 to the statment:
      #include <MsgBoxConstants.au3> Local $aArray[10] = [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10] Local $iMyNumber = 0 For $i = 0 To UBound($aArray) - 1 $iMyNumber += $aArray[$i] Next MsgBox($MB_OK, "Sum of all Numbers!", $iMyNumber) Q #5. Can an Array contain an Array? How do I access an Array within an Array?
      A. Yes! It is possible that an Array can contain another Array! Here is an example of an Array within an Array:
      ; An Array can contain another Array in one of its elements ; Let me show you an example of what I mean ;) #include <Array.au3> Global $aArray[2] $aArray[0] = "Foo" Global $aChildArray[1] = ["Bar"] $aArray[1] = $aChildArray _ArrayDisplay($aArray) ; Did you see that!? The 2nd element is an {Array} :O ; But how do we access it??? ; You almost guessed it, like this: ; Just envolope the element which contains the {Array} (as shown in _ArrayDisplay) with brackets (or parentheses)! :D ConsoleWrite(($aArray[1])[0]) ; NOTE the brackets () around $aArray[1]!!! They are required or you would get an syntax error! ; So this: $aArray[1][0] wont work!  
      More FAQs coming soon!
    • simonc8
      By simonc8
      I have a script which executes sleep for a couple of hours then carries out instructions. Does the running AutoIt script prevent the computer from entering sleep mode during this time? If not, is there something I can add to the AutoIt script to keep the computer awake?
      Grateful for advice.
    • gahhon
      By gahhon
      Hi,
      I have a program that is read data from the .txt file, since the .txt file is only readable, viewable and editable for the admin user.
      But how could I lock it with password, or some other technique that can helps to achieve this?
      Thanks for the advanced information.
    • gahhon
      By gahhon
      Hi,
      How can I the trigger the another button functions without waiting the previous function to finish execute?
      Any advise?
      I couldn't find any relevant topics via google.
      Thanks a lot.
    • SharpDressedMan
      By SharpDressedMan
      Hi all,
      I need to use ControlMove() on some controls of a hidden GUI window.
      This works properly on a GUI window created with default style, but does not work on a GUI window created with style $WS_OVERLAPPEDWINDOW
      func GUItest($bOverlapped) $m = GUICreate("test", 200, 100, -1, -1, $bOverlapped ? $WS_OVERLAPPEDWINDOW : -1) $g = GUICtrlCreateButton("test", 0, 0) ControlMove($m, "", $g, 30, 30) GUISetState() endfunc GuiTest(false) ; button 'test' properly moved to (30,30) GuiTest(true) ; button 'test' not moved and still sitting at (0,0) Any reason for this unexpected behavior ?
      Any workaround to fix this ?
      Thanks for any help
×