Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
kcvinu

Traditional C style gui making vs subclassing

Recommended Posts

Hi all,

We can make guis with GUICreate function.  As well as, we can create guis in traditional C style with _WinAPI_CreateWindowEx function. Well, in the second case, we have the power and freedom to deal with WndProc function and thus we can do a lot more than the ordinary GUICreate function. But We can do the same things in ordinary GUICreate function with the help of  _WinAPI_SetWindowSubclass function and _WinAPI_RemoveWindowSubclass function. But i think we can't do anything in the WM_CREATE, WM_PAINT messages. (Please correct me if i am wrong).

So my question is; 

Which method is better ?

ordinary GUICreate function with subclassing OR _WinAPI_CreateWindowEx with original WndProc ?

Why i am asking this because, i need more control over my guis with maximum safety without performance loss.

 

Edited by kcvinu

My Contributions

UDF Link Viewer   --- A tool to visit the links of some most important UDFs 

 Includer_2  ----- A tool to type the #include statement automatically 

 Digits To Date  ----- date from 3 integer values

PrintList ----- prints arrays into console for testing.

 Alert  ------ An alternative for MsgBox 

 MousePosition ------- A simple tooltip display of mouse position

GRM Helper -------- A littile tool to help writing code with GUIRegisterMsg function

Access_UDF  -------- An UDF for working with access database files. (.*accdb only)

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you create the parent GUI with _WinAPI_CreateWindowEx you can't use any of the native GUICtrlCreate-functions and you can't use any of the native functions that uses a controlID as parameter. In that way you have ruled out a substantial part of the native functions related to GUI creation and maintenance. This means that you have to create and update the controls with the functions in the GUI UDFs.

When you create controls with the functions in the GUI UDFs a true window handle is returned (not a controlID). You are going to use the control handle to update the controls.

Many functions in the GUI UDFs are divided into two parts. Often a short and fast part in case that the control handle turns out to be a native controlID, and a longer and slower part in case it's a true window handle. Because all your control handles are true window handles, you'll always be executing the longer and slower part of the UDF function.

Your requirement of no performance loss will not hold.

The development process will take significantly longer time. As a test, try to create a window with _WinAPI_CreateWindowEx and add a group control, a label and an updown control.

You are able to catch WM_PAINT messages by subclassing the controls.

It's not easy to catch WM_CREATE messages. But most code that can be executed in response to a WM_CREATE message can also be executed immediately after the control is created and before it's visible in the GUI. Why is it so crucial to execute the code in response to a WM_CREATE message?

The best method is definitely to use GUICreate and then use subclassing in cases where it's necessary. In that way you get all the benefits of the native GUI-functions, and because of the controlIDs you get faster code when you use the functions in the GUI UDFs.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@LarsJ ,

Thanks for your detailed reply. This reply enlightened me very well. I asked this question because, i am planning to make a different IDE for autoit which can help user to make powerull C style guis. That's why i am practising all messages from WM_CREATE to WM_QUIT. All the existing IDEs are using ordinary gui creation funcions. 

Anyway, according to you, using subclassing is the best bet for me.  Now, i need to practice all types of mesages with subclassing. Thanks again. You gave such a brilliant guidance. :)


My Contributions

UDF Link Viewer   --- A tool to visit the links of some most important UDFs 

 Includer_2  ----- A tool to type the #include statement automatically 

 Digits To Date  ----- date from 3 integer values

PrintList ----- prints arrays into console for testing.

 Alert  ------ An alternative for MsgBox 

 MousePosition ------- A simple tooltip display of mouse position

GRM Helper -------- A littile tool to help writing code with GUIRegisterMsg function

Access_UDF  -------- An UDF for working with access database files. (.*accdb only)

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By TXTechie
      Hello Everyone,
      I've developed my own GUI using AutoIt and I'm allowing users to minimize the GUI, but I also want to include some kind of timer so that it will automatically restore the GUI after something like 30 minutes or an hour. However, I also want them to be able to manually restore the GUI by clicking the application's icon in the taskbar.
      I've searched through the forums, but I'm not sure how to get started.
      Any ideas or functions to research are appreciated!
      Regards,
      TX Techie
    • By Rskm
      Hi, recently i created a GUI for some calculations in AutoIT.  The GUI has 2 tabs and on the first tab, it has few inputboxes where i use to click with mouse and start entering the inputs. i recently made some changes in the position of these textboxes. I made this by changing the autoit code file instead of making changes in KODA. Now i cannot click inside these textboxes with mouse. However, i can use TAB key to cycle through/enter input in these input boxes. what could have made the inputboxes not responding to mouseclicks. thanks
    • By TheDcoder
      Hi everyone,
      I am bit stumped as to why I am not able to set the time in the Date control
      #include <DateTimeConstants.au3> #include <GUIConstantsEx.au3> #include <MsgBoxConstants.au3> Example() Func Example() GUICreate("My GUI get date", 200, 200, 800, 200) Local $idDate = GUICtrlCreateDate("1953/04/25", 10, 10, 185, 20, $DTS_TIMEFORMAT) ; to select a specific default format Local $sStyle = "HH:mm:ss" GUICtrlSendMsg($idDate, $DTM_SETFORMATW, 0, $sStyle) ; Set time Local $iRet = GUICtrlSetData($idDate, '13:33:37') ConsoleWrite('GUICtrlSetData returned ' & ($iRet = 1 ? 'success' : 'failure') & @CRLF) GUISetState(@SW_SHOW) ; Loop until the user exits. While GUIGetMsg() <> $GUI_EVENT_CLOSE WEnd MsgBox($MB_SYSTEMMODAL, "Time", GUICtrlRead($idDate)) EndFunc ;==>Example The documentation for GUICtrlSetData clearly mentions that it uses the same format as GUICtrlRead:
      But I get failure
      What gives?
      Thanks for the help in advance!
    • By thedemons
      Introduction
      ImGui is a popular library written by ocornut, it can make awesome user interface based on directx. It is being used by many big apps/games.  The UI is nice and flexible, easy to use because of frame-by-frame drawing. So I decided to convert the entire ImGui library to AutoIt
      At first it's just an experiment, i converted some basic draw functions of imgui, compile to a dll, then using DllCall in autoit to call the functions. I was testing to see how much FPS i can get in autoit, and i was expected a low FPS, since autoit is slow. Suprisingly, the FPS turned out to be so high, it works really fast, even when drawing 1000 buttons at the same time. Features
      More than +270 functions converted from ImGui (compiled dll). Has 90% of the capability of what you can do in C++; Usable ImGuiIO and ImGuiStyle, so you can set whatever configurations you like. Preview
          
      Usage
      #include <WinAPI.au3> #include "ImGui.au3" ; Create a window Local $hwnd = _ImGui_GUICreate("AutoIt ImGui", 1024, 768) _WinAPI_ShowWindow($hwnd) ; Set style color _ImGui_StyleColorsLight() ;~ _ImGui_StyleColorsDark() Local $f_value = 5 While 1 ; when the user click close button on the window, this will return false if Not _ImGui_PeekMsg() Then Exit ; must call _ImGui_BeginFrame() _ImGui_Begin("Another window") _ImGui_Text("Hello there..") If _ImGui_Button("click me") Then $f_value = 5 _ImGui_SliderFloat("slider", $f_value, 2, 20) If _ImGui_IsItemHovered() Then _ImGui_ToolTip("what r u doing?") _ImGui_End() ; must call _ImGui_EndFrame() Wend  
      Remark
      Most of the functions were converted automatically. I haven't tested all of them yet, if some function doesn't work for you, please tell me. Still missing some features of ImGui, please tell me if you needed any. Run \tools\imgui-au3-setup.au3 to add _ImGui functions to SciTE auto-complete. Source Code
      Require: DirectX GitHub: imgui-autoit
    • By MesterPerfect
      good morning
      this is the first post here in the autoit forums
      i hope that you can help me in my problem
      i have a JSON encoded
      it a map of my forums
      where i want to make a treeview that have the same type of map
      e.g
      a system (as category)
      windows (as sub category)
      software (as an child item in the windows category)
      .....
      i don't know how to do that
      so, i know that i can do that using the json functions
      but i need your help about how we can do it as the type that i told you
      by the way i need to put the sub info for each item in an array that give me the ability to manage my items
      e.g
      can post thread
      can reply
      message cound ...
      you just give me a small example and i can continue.
      am sorry if this against the rules of the forum.
      but i realy searched a lot but i couldn't
      i hope some one give me the way.
      thank you very much in advance
       
      here is the link of json forum
      https://www.autoitscript.com/forum/topic/148114-a-non-strict-json-udf-jsmn/
      and here is my encoded json file
       
      { "tree_map": { "0": [ 1, 5, 6, 7 ], "1": [ 2 ], "2": [ 4 ], "5": [ 3 ], "6": [ 8 ], "8": [ 9, 10 ] }, "nodes": [ { "breadcrumbs": [], "description": "", "display_in_list": true, "display_order": 1, "node_id": 1, "node_name": null, "node_type_id": "Category", "parent_node_id": 0, "title": "Main category", "type_data": {} }, { "breadcrumbs": [ { "node_id": 1, "title": "Main category", "node_type_id": "Category" } ], "description": "", "display_in_list": true, "display_order": 1, "node_id": 2, "node_name": null, "node_type_id": "Forum", "parent_node_id": 1, "title": "Main forum", "type_data": { "allow_poll": true, "allow_posting": true, "can_create_thread": true, "can_upload_attachment": true, "discussion_count": 0, "last_post_date": 0, "last_post_id": 0, "last_post_username": "", "last_thread_id": 0, "last_thread_prefix_id": 0, "last_thread_title": "", "message_count": 0, "min_tags": 0, "require_prefix": false } }, { "breadcrumbs": [ { "node_id": 1, "title": "Main category", "node_type_id": "Category" }, { "node_id": 2, "title": "Main forum", "node_type_id": "Forum" } ], "description": "", "display_in_list": true, "display_order": 1, "node_id": 4, "node_name": null, "node_type_id": "Forum", "parent_node_id": 2, "title": "my forums1", "type_data": { "allow_poll": true, "allow_posting": true, "can_create_thread": true, "can_upload_attachment": true, "discussion_count": 0, "last_post_date": 0, "last_post_id": 0, "last_post_username": "", "last_thread_id": 0, "last_thread_prefix_id": 0, "last_thread_title": "", "message_count": 0, "min_tags": 0, "require_prefix": false } }, { "breadcrumbs": [], "description": "", "display_in_list": true, "display_order": 2, "node_id": 5, "node_name": null, "node_type_id": "Category", "parent_node_id": 0, "title": "Perfect", "type_data": {} }, { "breadcrumbs": [ { "node_id": 5, "title": "Perfect", "node_type_id": "Category" } ], "description": "", "display_in_list": true, "display_order": 2, "node_id": 3, "node_name": null, "node_type_id": "Forum", "parent_node_id": 5, "title": "ahmed", "type_data": { "allow_poll": true, "allow_posting": true, "can_create_thread": true, "can_upload_attachment": true, "discussion_count": 0, "last_post_date": 0, "last_post_id": 0, "last_post_username": "", "last_thread_id": 0, "last_thread_prefix_id": 0, "last_thread_title": "", "message_count": 0, "min_tags": 0, "require_prefix": false } }, { "breadcrumbs": [], "description": "", "display_in_list": true, "display_order": 3, "node_id": 6, "node_name": null, "node_type_id": "Forum", "parent_node_id": 0, "title": "autoit", "type_data": { "allow_poll": true, "allow_posting": true, "can_create_thread": true, "can_upload_attachment": true, "discussion_count": 0, "last_post_date": 0, "last_post_id": 0, "last_post_username": "", "last_thread_id": 0, "last_thread_prefix_id": 0, "last_thread_title": "", "message_count": 0, "min_tags": 0, "require_prefix": false } }, { "breadcrumbs": [ { "node_id": 6, "title": "autoit", "node_type_id": "Forum" } ], "description": "", "display_in_list": true, "display_order": 3, "node_id": 8, "node_name": null, "node_type_id": "Forum", "parent_node_id": 6, "title": "examples", "type_data": { "allow_poll": true, "allow_posting": true, "can_create_thread": true, "can_upload_attachment": true, "discussion_count": 0, "last_post_date": 0, "last_post_id": 0, "last_post_username": "", "last_thread_id": 0, "last_thread_prefix_id": 0, "last_thread_title": "", "message_count": 0, "min_tags": 0, "require_prefix": false } }, { "breadcrumbs": [ { "node_id": 6, "title": "autoit", "node_type_id": "Forum" }, { "node_id": 8, "title": "examples", "node_type_id": "Forum" } ], "description": "", "display_in_list": true, "display_order": 3, "node_id": 9, "node_name": null, "node_type_id": "Forum", "parent_node_id": 8, "title": "GUI", "type_data": { "allow_poll": true, "allow_posting": true, "can_create_thread": true, "can_upload_attachment": true, "discussion_count": 0, "last_post_date": 0, "last_post_id": 0, "last_post_username": "", "last_thread_id": 0, "last_thread_prefix_id": 0, "last_thread_title": "", "message_count": 0, "min_tags": 0, "require_prefix": false } }, { "breadcrumbs": [ { "node_id": 6, "title": "autoit", "node_type_id": "Forum" }, { "node_id": 8, "title": "examples", "node_type_id": "Forum" } ], "description": "", "display_in_list": true, "display_order": 31, "node_id": 10, "node_name": null, "node_type_id": "Forum", "parent_node_id": 8, "title": "windowEX", "type_data": { "allow_poll": true, "allow_posting": true, "can_create_thread": true, "can_upload_attachment": true, "discussion_count": 0, "last_post_date": 0, "last_post_id": 0, "last_post_username": "", "last_thread_id": 0, "last_thread_prefix_id": 0, "last_thread_title": "", "message_count": 0, "min_tags": 0, "require_prefix": false } }, { "breadcrumbs": [], "description": "", "display_in_list": true, "display_order": 4, "node_id": 7, "node_name": null, "node_type_id": "Category", "parent_node_id": 0, "title": "vbs", "type_data": {} } ] }  
×
×
  • Create New...